Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Mystery Solved
#1
Regarding Jim Alfaro and 7th Gear Designs - http://cb1100forum.com/forum/showthread.php?tid=7951 The mystery is solved, but what a mess. So here is the story of what is going on.

I have never met Jim personally. I contacted him after extensive exhaustive effort that many have mentioned they were not willing to do. Jim rarely (now make that never) answers phone calls or email. Rightly so, because he is a farce impersonating a manufacturer. I know manufacturing (my business) and Jim is no manufacturer. He apparently subs all of his work out. This would not even be so bad except he represents himself as the actual manufacturer.

In one of his few emails I received, he said there was a problem with the "blanks" (material) and that was causing a delay. That led me to check into PBI sprockets that provides blank sprockets (http://shop.pbisprockets.com/product.sc?...goryId=56) figuring he gets the xx tooth sprocket blanks from them then drills the mounting holes, but after talking to them, he never purchased from them. So maybe he is not lying - NOT! Their blanks are aluminum not steel anyway.

I was deciding if I should add this item to my company (start manufacturing sprockets) for the benefit of me and the forum and ....
I was at the point of turning this over to the police, when today to my sheer surprise, a box arrived from Azusa Engineering (http://www.azusaeng.com/) with 2 sprockets inside - no paperwork. A 19T & a 37T with 7GD lasered on the side. However, I was supposed to receive a 19T & a 35T from Jim. HMMM, another mess up to deal with.

After looking at the 37T, I realized a 35T is impossible. It will never fit/attach. The outside of the 5 attachment holes are within LESS than a SINGLE mm (see pic at end) of the center hub hole for the wheel shaft! So for him to have originally promised that the 35T will be possible to install/manufacture proves he doesn't even qualify as a viable "designer". He already "made" (make that sold) a 37T for Peking Duck and should have known especially when I asked the question.

So, this afternoon, I followed up with a call to Azusa Engineering and got "the Rest of the Story". I had originally in fact contacted them (along with a half dozen others) before I contacted 7GD. I spoke to their manufacturing supervisor that said the son (of the father and son team {owners}) was wanting to make steel sprockets, but the dad did not want to. After a few months of that, I came across Peking Duck's post and started a conversation with Jim. That story is above and .....one of the most UNPROFESSIONAl pieces of _____ I have had to deal with in decades.

As a manufacturer and my discussion with Azusa Engineering, I'll explain what happened - The machines that do this work require many hours to set up, required dedicated operation to the same material - aluminum,, steel, ... extensive time to change and clean out after a new different production material is to be used.

Well, Azusa Engineering, like my company uses aluminum for many reasons, and it will be months before a breakdown will be initiated and a swap over will occur for the few steel runs needed. So because 7GD does not manufacture the item, he had to keep coming up with new (one after the other) LIES to explain why the product has not shipped. When he ran out of lies, he just avoided answering the phone or email. One time his better half answered the phone on a Saturday by mistake while they were on vacation in Texas. All he had to do is tell the truth and I would have been patient, but NOOOOOOOOOOOO!

As part of my business, I am able to process/coat these items professionally. I am going to coat the 19T front with Bright Nickel and the 37T rear with Yellow Zinc. One bad item is that the $100 of Honda OEM parts I purchased for the 35T won't be needed for it to be installed/work. The good news is that I will not need to break the chain and use the parts to shorten it - initially, unless I think it should be.

Another item of good note, because I am not going to break the chain initially, I am going to do the R&R install myself because I won't need the special tools required for a chain mod. Bolt & unbolt.

I'll post before & after pics, but I did not want to delay getting this info out so that ALL may avoid a future disaster with 7GD. Should any 13CBs desire this steel vs aluminum sprocket mod, I will probably arrange future production runs - TBA.

Reply
#2
Why can't people just be honest about this stuff. If saves A LOT of hurt feelings and bad press. I would think that he has lost any chances of getting any more business for these bikes (at least from this site) and maybe more from his dishonesty.
Reply
#3
Thanks to all that have PM'd & posted support! It is the only bad issue I have heard of on this forum since I have been a member. It is such a Great Group! 'wish I could make this summer's ride, but can't.
Reply
#4
Thanks for the update, rbike. I'm glad something reasonable came out of it, but sorry you had to cop all the crap on the way through.
Reply
#5
Wow, this is all very profoundly interesting and disturbing at the same time.
Reply
#6
Peking Duck or Others (if have 1st hand info) - I'm reviewing all threads and advice before installation of mt 19T & 37T "Installation was a breeze. Here's a tip - to loosen or tighten sprocket nuts, do it with the wheel in place. Stand on the right side, put your foot on the rear brake, use a 19mm socket and a 1/2" drive ratchet/breaker bar, and you can break loose the nuts with ease. If you take the wheel off before loosening the nuts, you will be fighting to hold the wheel. Reassemble and torque the nuts in the same way - 80 ft/lbs torque."

I have a substantial impact wrench & compressor - Do you still suggest your method of loosening Q5 nuts before wheel removal? This may be moot, but the attention to detail I do in manufacturing, leaves no room for just guessing or assuming. I already made 1 mistake assuming 7GD was OK.
Reply
#7
Break the nuts loose with the wheel installed unless you have a way to clamp the wheel down to your work bench.
Reply
#8
kennyw, I'll try my impact wrench with everything still on and attached and attempt to loosen the Q5 sprocket nuts first - like plying with cool tools - lol. It should be not significantly different than a local tire change that doesn't need to keep wheel on the ground to loosen nuts before lifting the car on a lift. Impact wrenches usually have enough torque to overcome the initial momentum required. I don't think I'll even have to put the wheel in gear. I'll probably try it with the Tx in neutral first. I'm a few weeks out still (have to plate sprockets first, ...); I'll report back with everything I observe/learn.
Reply
#9
rbike, glad your problem was resolved. When I ordered my sprockets from him first, I was aware he did not personally manufacture them, and that it would be a fairly specialized, custom item. To tool up for one-offs, especially material change, takes some effort. I had contacted every sprocket manufacurer I could find, including Azusa, and almost nobody wanted to make them in steel. Now we know why. (One other source made me one after several attempts, but still unhappy with result).

In my opinion, the steel sprocket was worth the effort for me and for some others who got them in a more timely manner. In the debate between steel and aluminum, the increased durability of steel would, for me, make aluminum a no-go.

As far as the removal and installation instructions, an impact wrench is fine for removal, but you still have to hold the wheel to torque the nuts.

In regards to the last point:

"After looking at the 37T, I realized a 35T is impossible. It will never fit/attach. The outside of the 5 attachment holes are within LESS than a SINGLE mm (see pic at end) of the center hub hole for the wheel shaft! So for him to have originally promised that the 35T will be possible to install/manufacture proves he doesn't even qualify as a viable "designer". He already "made" (make that sold) a 37T for Peking Duck and should have known especially when I asked the question."

The recessed portion is for clearance for the flange nut - it has no bearing on the strength or function of the sprocket. If the recessed area overlapped the center hole, not a problem at all, so a 35T, or less, is easily possible. This should be obvious to anyone looking at it. This, along with your prior comments and questions on chains, all makes me question how you are qualified to criticize someone else who is a designer.

Can you explain what is meant that "35T" is impossible?
Reply
#10
PD, I did not see your reply the other day when you posted it due to the limited time posts are on the forum home page. I do not know if you are trying to defend 7GD or what, but as a manufacturer, I know manufacturing and he is no manufacturer.

I do not know every manufacturer's ability, knowledge, or what machinery they have access to, but in this case to make this product efficiently and cost effectively, one needs to do Wire EDM - see the Wikipedia link for details (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical...achining). If my company were to do manufacture these sprockets with our CNC machines, they would cost into the 4 figures each for T&M. Hence that is why a dedicated wire EDM manufacturer that has the templates is the way to go and I choose not to do it myself.

Regarding my post "After looking at the 37T, I realized a 35T is impossible. It will never fit/attach", I was not trying to get deeply specific because some get "headaches", but if you look at the picture, I drew an arrow to the inside edge of the Q5 nuts that attach to the wheel studs. There is less than a SINGLE mm clearance. If the sprocket was reduced to a 35T the edge of the nuts would be over an open area of the sprocket that would eventually leading to sprocket failure due to uneven loading on the sprocket surface!

I did contact Azusa Engineering before 7GD, but there were internal differences on wanting to manufacturer sprockets in steel. I kept looking and came upon your post. I wish I hadn't. Regarding him being a designer, 7GD was to do a 35T and DIDN'T, because IMHO he had no idea how or Azusa didn't, or they agreed a 35T was not viable. I never received a 35T. He had Azusa ship me another 37T like yours.

"The recessed portion is for clearance for the flange nut - it has no bearing on the strength or function of the sprocket. If the recessed area overlapped the center hole, not a problem at all, so a 35T, or less, is easily possible. This should be obvious to anyone looking at it. This, along with your prior comments and questions on chains, all makes me question how you are qualified to criticize someone else who is a designer." I don't think you understand the mechanical engineering and stresses involved (explained above) from your reply. In no way am I trying to upset you personally, but I am significantly qualified and he is a ________!

Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Fast Idle Problem Solved Nachodaddy 17 969 10-08-2022, 09:18 AM
Last Post: PowerDubs_imp
  Mystery dent on frame? Should I be worried? bertypower_imp 14 757 10-04-2020, 02:41 AM
Last Post: bertypower_imp
  Mystery 'R' pin WK57ABF_imp 23 776 09-30-2017, 11:28 AM
Last Post: Houtman_imp

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)