Mazda Miata?

[Jim21680_imp]

I'm also a huge fan of the S2000, enough to have one parked out front. But I agree with others: finding a clean one at a decent price is becoming increasingly difficult.
The Miata is a worthy alternative, but I'll throw you a curveball....have you considered a Jeep Wrangler?

With the roof and doors off, it's a very "lively" ride. Absolutely 100% fun, even if in a different way than a sports car. You can easily find one with a 6spd, and 4wd will always be nice for those Jersey winters; even take it to the beach if you want. Plus, you can continue to enjoy the wave to fellow owners that we all enjoy on our bikes.

If you haven't driven one, it's at least worth a test drive if you care to. Good luck!