Modern Scramblers: yay or nay?

[the Ferret]

I like the looks of street scramblers, particularly the new Triumphs, more so than the new Ducati's. My first "big" street bike was a Honda 305 scrambler, and prior to that I had ridden a friends BSA 650 Scrambler. But imo these are really street bikes than can do fireroads, mild dirt trails etc and never intended to be real " dirt bikes" even though some people are capable of taking them there. Feel the same way about ADV bikes, so these are no different than ADV bikes imo.